The Quintessential Blog

What are good ideas if you don't care to share them?

April 22, 2017 BY PATRICK ALBINA

The Hummingbird Effect, the power of innovation through evolution

During a recent Defence program that I delivered, I was explaining about the difference between conventional Project Management (PM) and complex PM.  Complex PM presents a situation where project managers are not in full control of all the factors given the dynamic and constantly changing conditions. Consequently the project manager needs to redefine their expectations around their ability to plan, and be open minded to the solutions that naturally emerge from the people in their project.  One of the course participants asked me that if we eventually learn all the possible combinations and outcomes, then they wouldn’t be complex projects anymore and therefore we could treat them in a conventional manner.  This is theoretically possible, and I guess that this represents a perpetual activity of act-review-reflect, i.e., you can strive for it, but you never actually get there.  It highlights the importance of continual learning and adapting to the conditions presented.  It also reminded me of a phenomenon called the Hummingbird Effect in which the value of hindsight and experience is leveraged to deliver better future outcomes – not by deliberate planning, but a combination of intent and emergence.  I hope that you enjoy the story!

Hummingbirds derive their name from the humming sound created as they beat their wings. They hover in mid-air at rapid wing-flapping rates, typically around 50 times per second, which creates frequencies that are audible to humans, i.e., a hum! However, what is truly fascinating about this is how the Hummingbird evolved their ability to hover in mid-air.

Sometime during the Cretaceous age (about 100 million years ago), flowers began to evolve colors and scents. This signaled the presence of pollen to insects, which correspondingly evolved sophisticated means to extract the pollen and, inadvertently, fertilize other flowers with pollen. Over time, the flowers supplemented the pollen with even more energy-rich nectar to lure the insects into the rituals of pollination. Bees and other insects evolved the sensory tools to see and be drawn to flowers, just as the flowers evolved the properties that attract bees.

The co-evolution between flowering plants and insects that led to the production of nectar ultimately created an opportunity for much larger animals — the humble hummingbird — to extract the nectar. In order to do this, the hummingbird had to evolve a highly unique form of flight mechanics that enabled them to hover alongside the flower in a way that few birds can even come close to doing. In other words, they had to learn an entirely new way to fly. The hummingbird doesn’t flap its wings up and down like other birds. Its wings oscillate in a circular motion, forming a figure eight, and the bird gets lift both from its downstroke — like all birds — and also from its upstroke.

These complex chains of interconnected events define the hummingbird effect. Although derived from the famous butterfly effect concept from chaos theory – Edward Lorenz’s famous metaphor for the idea that a change as imperceptible as the flap of a butterfly’s wings can result in an effect as grand as a storm far away several weeks later, the two concepts differ in a very fundamental way.

  • The butterfly effect involves an intricate chain of events, i.e., you can’t map the link between the air molecules bouncing around the butterfly and the storm system brewing across the ocean. They are connected, only because everything is connected at some level, but it is far beyond our capacity to logically break down those connections and, even harder, to predict them in advance.

  • The hummingbird effect involves a subtle connection between the flower and the hummingbird. Whilst they are very different organisms with very different needs and different biological systems, the flower clearly interacts with the hummingbird, influencing it in a direct and intelligible way that results in a natural biomechanical innovation.

The hummingbird effect demonstrates that an event in one field can trigger completely unexpected outcomes in wholly different domains. This connectivity cannot be predicted or planned, and it is only knowable in retrospect. It represents the characteristics of complexity, i.e., its behavior is a non-linear evolution through the interaction of many factors that cannot be planned or controlled, and through which new and novel possibilities are revealed.  Making sense of what happened is only possible in hindsight.

Nature loves complexity, and there is a lot that we can learn from it. We live in an increasingly unstable and unpredictable world with a rate of change that is only increasing. Many events we encounter almost always comes as a surprise because things these days don’t happen as a planned and controllable process. Connections are made by accident, there are unintended consequences and seemingly unrelated factors come together to form completely new possibilities. Second-guessing the outcomes in a planned or analytical manner is difficult because when people or things or ideas come together in new ways, an evolution occurs. In fact serendipity can serve as a silent partner in the process of emergent change as many notable ideas and innovations have come about as the byproduct of an unplanned and an unexpected set of circumstances. Just consider for a moment…

The microwave oven was conceived from a melted candy bar, saccharin from an accidental chemical spill, and conventional film chemistry was discovered when mercury vapors from a broken thermometer expectedly developed a photographic image.  Probably the most famous example of accidental innovation is Alexander Fleming’s discovery of the antibiotic properties of penicillin. Fleming unintentionally left a dish of Staphylococcus bacteria uncovered for a few days and returned to find the dish dotted with bacterial growth, except in one area where a patch of mold (Penicillium notatum) was growing.

Fleming himself said of this event,

“I did not ask for a spore of Penicillium notatum to drop on my culture plate, and when I saw certain changes, I had not the slightest suspicion that I was at the beginning of something extraordinary.”

Unplanned events happen, and we’re all better off because they do.

Innovation can’t always be planned and accidents happen that lead us down entirely different pathways. The key here is to be open-minded to the unexpected and recognise serendipitous opportunity. Here are some suggestions on how to enable innovation to emerge through leveraging complexity:

  1. Create an environment that fosters and values diversity of thoughts, exploring conflicting ideas rather than trying to seek a consensus
  2. Seek to understand the nature of breakthrough ideas in your industry and plan accordingly
  3. Reflect on past events in hindsight and loosen control of future events to enable new possibilities to emerge
  4. Leverage the power of combination rather than isolation, i.e., use ‘AND’ rather than ‘OR’
  5. Treat failure as contextual – never discard ideas that didn’t work as intended under an initial set of circumstances – it may be a golden nugget that you are looking for in a different context

Sometimes genius arrives not by choice — but by chance, and nature has a way to make these seemingly strange leaps of evolution, i.e., the sexual reproduction strategies of plants end up shaping the design of a hummingbird’s wings. Had there been naturalists around to observe the insects first evolving pollination behavior alongside the flowering plants, they would have logically assumed that this strange new ritual had nothing to do with avian life. And yet this chain of events ended up precipitating one of the most astonishing physical transformations in the evolutionary history of birds. Although the traces of those original influences often remain obscure, they are nevertheless retrospectively detectable with the passage of time. The retrospective knowability of the hummingbird effect offers us insights and learning as to how to manage and navigate our way through complexity and, along the way, reveal new ideas, innovations, and astonishing possibilities to us.

Herein lies the remarkable power and reach of the hummingbird effect.